Skip to main content

Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret: Review

 


Judy Blume novels have been a staple for pre-teens everywhere, and even when schools decided to pull the books from schools, that didn’t stop young girls from picking up Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret. For a book to be so beloved by adults who grew up reading Blume, it’s essential reading. And now, Kelly Fremon Craig’s adaptation is essential viewing. A 12-year-old girl named Margaret (Abby Ryder Forston) moves to New Jersey and has to start at a new school. This heartfelt coming-of-age film explores the pressure of making new friends, waiting to become a woman, and choosing a religion. Fremon Craig does a wonderful job of incorporating every aspect of the book and making a well-rounded film about what it is to be a woman. 

The beauty of the Blume novel is that many issues are discussed while Margaret questions everything. She has conversations with God about when she will become a woman and doesn’t know if she will be Christian or Jewish. As she talks to God, Margaret has an identity crisis in middle school. Her parents are Christian, and Jewish decided not to raise her in either religion. On top of feeling far behind the other girls, as all girls do when waiting to become a woman, Margaret does not have a community to call her own. She struggles with the idea that maybe someone in the universe isn’t listening in to help her because she isn’t getting what she wants as quickly as she would like. There is this perfect balance that Blume and Fremon Craig achieve in this film that has all these issues Margaret’s facing woven together. 

Not only do we see Margaret struggling, but we see her mother, Barbara (Rachel McAdams), struggle with the decision she has made. She was raised a devout Christian, and her parents disowned her because she fell in love with Herb (Benny Safdie), who was Jewish. She never saw her parents again. Once she moved to New Jersey, she felt lost and even gave up her teaching position to stay home and help Margaret with the adjustment. She didn’t anticipate Margaret finding a group of friends so quickly. So Barbara feels alone in the house as she is left with her thoughts about the current state of her life. We also see her grandmother Sylvia (Kathy Bates) attempt to handle her loneliness because her family moved away. Fremon Craig and Blume subtly create a layered generational story. 

Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret is one of the best book adaptations. Abby Ryder Forston gives an endearing and heartfelt performance as Margaret and brings this character to life. Blume shows that there is no right way to be a woman. And you’re never behind. You’re simply growing at your own pace. Fremon Craig explores the fast-tracked societal pressures of becoming a woman, only for that moment to be terrifying because of what’s to come. Blume normalized menstruation, religion, and sexual questions being asked, and that’s why it is essential viewing for anyone heading into middle school. It’s incredibly emotional and will bring you back to those early days. Fortunately, when watching this as an adult, you can relate to Margaret. But also have that reassurance that even though life gets hard as a woman, it somehow gets better. 

4/5 

Review by: Amanda Guarragi 

#moviereviews #filmreviews #filmcritic #1stReviews #RachelMcAdams #KellyFremonCraig #JudyBlume #BennySafdie #KathyBates #AbbyRyderForster #ComingOfAge

Popular posts from this blog

Boss Level Film Review

       Boss Level is a new addition to the time loop genre, with a twist. Ex-special forces officer, Roy Pulver, played by Frank Grillo, relives the same day until he dies. Every day he is hunted by assassins and when killed, he wakes up back in his bed where he started, only to have to try and survive all over again. Roy has no idea why he is stuck in this infinite time loop but he must do what he can to survive, and the longer he survives, the more he uncovers about his particular situation.  Unlike most action films that take time to build up, this film gets right into it and offers tons of non-stop combat sequences that would satisfy any lover of action films. Its erratic flow makes for some fun action scenes which come out of nowhere since Roy can expect the assassins to attack at any moment. If you play video games often and have ever been stuck on a level for hours or even days, you know the feeling of having to repeat the same thing over and over again u...

Godzilla vs. Kong Film Review

         Godzilla versus Kong is the action movie we have been longing for since all major blockbuster films pushed back their release dates. After three solo films between Kong and Godzilla, we finally see the two titans clash on film for the first time in what is the culmination of the Universal Monsterverse. The story is split nicely in two as team Kong and team Godzilla each have their own mission. Team Kong is on a secret mission to the center of the earth to uncover the mystery of the titans. This team consists of Dr. Nathan, Dr. Ilene, Maia, and the Youngest character in the film, Jia. Team Godzilla consists of Madison, Josh, and Bernie who are also on a secret mission, to infiltrate Apex Cybernetics with the theory that they are up to no good and are the reason why Godzilla has been acting up recently. The dynamics of the teams are well balanced as the Kong story provides us with serious and more action-heavy bits in contrast to the Apex team story that ...

Inside Out 2 | Review by: Stefano Bove

  Nine years ago, Pixar introduced us to Riley, a young girl who is trying to grow with change happening with herself and her family. Her emotions; joy, anger, sadness, fear and disgust help her through these difficult times.   Now two years, Riley is 13 and is going through new life changes physically and emotionally as she tries to grip with the reality that the rest of her life relies on how the next weekend goes. All of these changes spark new emotions to grow inside of her.  It is a tough time for Riley that she must overcome. It is a snapshot in time that is probably a big emotional trigger for audiences as well as we go on this journey with Riley. Taking the incredibly intricate memory world that was established in the first film, the sequel makes a few minor additions that allow it to feel familiar but still fresh enough to keep us engaged. Many of these new additions are some of the funniest moments in the entire series.  With more emotions and human charact...